• iTunes
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Email
  • Home
  • Courses
  • eBooks
  • Library
  • ET Club
  • BST LIVE
  • Leasing
  • About
Better System Trader

Better System Trader

Better System Trader is the podcast and blog dedicated to systematic traders, providing practical tips from trading experts around the world.

026 – Systematic Trading Techniques – Robert Carver

http://traffic.libsyn.com/bettersystemtrader/BetterSystemTrader-Ep26-RobertCarver.mp3
Play in New Window|Download

Headshot

Robert Carver is an independent systematic trader, freelance writer and research consultant.

He spent more than seven years working for AHL, one of the worlds largest systematic hedge funds.  Robert was responsible for the inception of AHL’s fundamental strategies group and subsequently managed the fund’s $5bn fixed income portfolio.

He is the author of “Systematic Trading: A unique new way to make investment and trading decisions.”

Before that he worked for CEPR, an economics think tank, as a research manager; and as an exotic derivatives trader for Barclays Capital.

In this episode we discuss trading rules, what makes a good trading rule and the advantages of using continuous rather than binary rules. He also shares insights into over-fitting and the challenges of walk-forward testing that can make it impractical.

Sponsors

Trade View Investments, a proprietary trading firm based in Melbourne, Australia, offer trading courses for beginner to advanced traders. Learn how to create automated trading strategies for Forex and Indices just like they do.

TradeViewInvestments-728x90_1

TradeViewInvestments-728x90_2

The Intermediate Workshop is also available as an intensive 2-day workshop in-house. Click here to learn more.

Show your support

While you’re listening, it would be great if you could show your support by leaving a brief review of the podcast in iTunes. This really helps to spread the word and reach even more listeners!

A very easy way to avoid over-fitting is to do no fitting at all

Click To Tweet

Topics discussed

  • What makes a good trading rule
  • The advantages of simple rules
  • Why only some trading rules are profitable
  • Walk-forward testing and some of the challenges that can make it impractical
  • How much data you actually need to determine if a trading rule is better than another
  • Why choosing the optimal values during a walk-forward test is not the best approach and some alternatives
  • Weighting trading rules
  • Steps to avoid over-fitting
  • Should trading rules be adjusted for individual instruments?
  • Continuous trading rules compared to binary rules
  • The applications and advantages of continuous trading rules
  • What makes a good systematic trader
  • The issues that overconfidence creates in trading
  • Two aspects of institutional trading that most retail traders could apply to their own trading

Resources mentioned in this episode

  • Robert can be followed on his blog or on twitter @investingidiocy
  • Recommended books:

Watch these 2 MTA presentations by Robert on systematic trading

MTAPresentation1

MTAPresentation2

Quotes

Most people do far more fitting than they need to or should do

Click To Tweet

Most trading rules don’t really work in a binary way 

Click To Tweet

Be diligent when creating systems but lazy when running them

Click To Tweet

A good system shouldn’t need to be meddled with

Click To Tweet

Traders worry too much about day to day returns, they’re essentially random

Click To Tweet

One down day doesn’t mean your system is broken

Click To Tweet

Top tips from this episode

Here are few of my favourite takeaways from the chat with Robert:

  • The challenges of walk forward testing – Robert highlighted issues with rolling window or walk forward analysis, especially around the length of the window that’s used. If we’re using a rolling window of 1 or 2 years, which is a common approach, is that length of time really long enough to determine one rule or variation is better than another? Robert suggested that it probably isn’t and provided an approach where you start with an expanding window until you get a window size that provides statistical significance and then use a rolling window from there. He also mentioned a study which suggests that choosing the best set of rules or values in a walk forward test is not the best approach and offered some suggestions that could provide better results.
  • “A very easy way to avoid over-fitting is to do no fitting at all” – I found this statement quite amusing at the time but it’s really a very interesting idea. If we’re using trading concepts that have been proven to work, what is fitting really doing for us? Roberts approach to using an ‘average of the rules’ was a very interesting concept because we just don’t know which rules are going to work best in the future.
  • Trading rules that are continuous rather than binary – Another idea I found very interesting was using continuous trading rules instead of binary. The use of a continuous rule not only tells you when to get in and out of trades but can also be used to drive position sizing. In the example Robert gave of the moving average crossover rule, you enter the trade with a small position when the crossover occurs, when the instrument starts moving in your favour you increase the position size and when the moving averages start moving back together you reduce the position size.

Transcript

Got A Question, Topic or Guest you want to see on the Podcast?

Do you have a specific question, topic or guest you’d like to see on a future podcast episode?

Click here and submit your suggestion for a chance to have it featured on an upcoming podcast episode.

Subscribe to Better System Trader and never miss another episode!

subscribe-with-itunes-button stitcher soundcloud android

Please support the podcast by giving an honest Rating/Review for the show on iTunes!

Episode Released:

27 September 2015

  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • twitter
  • google+
  • pinterest
  • stumbleupon
025 - The importance of creativi...
027 - Mindfulness in Trading - D...

Related Posts

  • 022 – Prop Trading & using statistics to find an edge – Robert Bubalovski
  • Stitching data for a more ‘balanced’ backtest
  • 047 – Backtesting & Execution – Nitesh Khandelwal
  • 196 – “How to avoid curve fitting using independent testing” – Jeff Swanson
  • 037 – Stop Losses with Cesar Alvarez

Comments

  1. Ken Jarrad

    September 29, 2015 at 8:02 am

    If you live in the UK then the book is cheaper from Books Etc. than Amazon.

    http://www.booksetc.co.uk/books/view/systematic-trading-9780857194459
    http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/0857194453

    • Andrew Swanscott

      September 29, 2015 at 8:12 am

      Thanks for the tip Ken!

      Andrew.

Trackbacks

  1. Quantocracy's Daily Wrap for 09/27/2015 | Quantocracy says:
    September 28, 2015 at 3:16 pm

    […] Interview with Robert Carver [Better System Trader] Robert Carver is an independent systematic trader, freelance writer and research consultant. He spent more than seven years working for AHL, one of the worlds largest systematic hedge funds. Robert was responsible for the inception of AHLs fundamental strategies group and subsequently managed the funds $5bn fixed income portfolio. He is the author of Systematic Trading: A unique new way […]

  2. Best Links of the Week | Quantocracy says:
    October 4, 2015 at 7:14 pm

    […] Interview with Robert Carver [Better System Trader] […]

  3. IMHO BEST LINKS FROM QUANTOCRACY FOR THE WEEK 28 SEP 15 — 4 OCT 15 | Quantitative Investor Blog says:
    October 5, 2015 at 8:07 am

    […] Robert Carver […]

Want to build robust trading strategies that actually work in live trading?

Click for more details

How do you REALLY know your strategies aren't just over-optimized rubbish?

Get this handy optimization checklist from veteran trader Bob Pardo, and make sure you haven’t made any of these mistakes that could lead to strategy failure.

Click to download now

What pro traders are saying about BST

"Andrew is a master at asking difficult and relevant questions."

Perry Kaufman perrykaufman.com

"I get some of my best ideas from listening to other market participants and Better System Trader is a great resource of conversations with trading professionals."

Michael Cook thetradingmasterclass.com

"Better System Trader is an invaluable resource that I've gleaned tremendous amounts of information from over the years. I wouldn't be the trader I am today without having found this resource. Please keep up the great work."

David Bergstrom buildalpha.com

"If you have been looking for that little extra nugget to transform your trading, you will find it at Better System Trader."

Laurent Bernut alphasecurecapital.com

"If I had to listen to one trading podcast only, it would be Better System Trader. I am always learning new things and getting research ideas from Andrew’s guests."

Cesar Alvarez alvarezquanttrading.com

"What really makes the BST podcast stand out is that Andrew is also an experienced trader and can therefore provide incomparable quality and depth in any interview. Thank you for endless inspiration."

Tomas Nesnidal systemsontheroad.com

"The Better System Trader podcasts have become an invaluable resource... There's no other podcast around that covers the subject in so much breadth and depth."

Alan Clement helixtrader.com

"Professional, to the point and relevant content. Better System Trader should be followed by anyone with an interest in our field."

Andreas Clenow followingthetrend.com

"The key to better system trading is information.  As a system trader himself, Andrew has unique capability of asking insightful questions that extract the skills of each guest."

John Ehlers www.mesasoftware.com

"I really enjoy listening to the Better System Trader podcasts. Even though I am in the industry for over 15 years, there is always something new to learn from these. Thank you!"

Martin Lembak striker.com

"Being a trader himself, Andrew drives insightful conversations that uncover gems of practical knowledge that can improve your trading today"

Kris Longmore robotwealth.net

"This podcast provides unique information, from real traders, interviewed by an experienced trader."

Kevin Davey kjtradingsystems.com

"The right questions to the right people at the right time."

Nick Radge thechartist.com.au

"BetterSystemTrader is an amazing resource of valuable information, Andrew is always able to ask the right question at the right time to deliver the best content possible, a must listen for anybody interested in trading!"

Andrea Unger skilledacademy.com

"Andrew loves traders and draws the most informative and engaging responses out of them."

Art Collins artcollinstrading.com

"Andrew seems to have a knack for getting the world's most famous traders to share valuable insights about how they trade for the benefit of the trading community."

Andrew Gibbs halifaxonline.co.nz

"Andrew has interviewed some great people and I have picked up some useful new insights. His integrity, trading knowledge, light-hearted attitude, curiosity and enthusiasm shine through and enhance each of his podcasts. Given the quality of the information and the price (free!) any serious trader would have to be a fool to not take advantage. Keep it up my friend."

Bob Pardo pardocapital.com

Trading stocks, options, futures and forex involves significant risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

© 2015 Better System Trader · Disclaimer & Terms · Privacy Policy · Sponsor